Download What This Cruel War Was Over: Soldiers, Slavery, and the Civil War, by Chandra Manning
To conquer the issue, we now provide you the innovation to purchase guide What This Cruel War Was Over: Soldiers, Slavery, And The Civil War, By Chandra Manning not in a thick published file. Yeah, reading What This Cruel War Was Over: Soldiers, Slavery, And The Civil War, By Chandra Manning by online or getting the soft-file only to check out can be among the methods to do. You might not really feel that reading an e-book What This Cruel War Was Over: Soldiers, Slavery, And The Civil War, By Chandra Manning will be beneficial for you. However, in some terms, May individuals effective are those that have reading practice, included this kind of this What This Cruel War Was Over: Soldiers, Slavery, And The Civil War, By Chandra Manning
What This Cruel War Was Over: Soldiers, Slavery, and the Civil War, by Chandra Manning
Download What This Cruel War Was Over: Soldiers, Slavery, and the Civil War, by Chandra Manning
What do you do to begin reading What This Cruel War Was Over: Soldiers, Slavery, And The Civil War, By Chandra Manning Searching the publication that you enjoy to check out first or discover an interesting publication What This Cruel War Was Over: Soldiers, Slavery, And The Civil War, By Chandra Manning that will make you desire to read? Everybody has distinction with their reason of checking out an e-book What This Cruel War Was Over: Soldiers, Slavery, And The Civil War, By Chandra Manning Actuary, reading behavior has to be from earlier. Many individuals might be love to review, yet not an e-book. It's not fault. An individual will be tired to open up the thick book with little words to check out. In even more, this is the genuine condition. So do happen most likely with this What This Cruel War Was Over: Soldiers, Slavery, And The Civil War, By Chandra Manning
Checking out, as soon as even more, will certainly give you something brand-new. Something that you have no idea after that disclosed to be populared with the book What This Cruel War Was Over: Soldiers, Slavery, And The Civil War, By Chandra Manning notification. Some knowledge or driving lesson that re got from reading e-books is vast. Much more publications What This Cruel War Was Over: Soldiers, Slavery, And The Civil War, By Chandra Manning you review, even more knowledge you get, and also more possibilities to always like reviewing books. As a result of this factor, checking out book ought to be begun from earlier. It is as exactly what you can get from guide What This Cruel War Was Over: Soldiers, Slavery, And The Civil War, By Chandra Manning
Obtain the perks of reviewing routine for your lifestyle. Schedule What This Cruel War Was Over: Soldiers, Slavery, And The Civil War, By Chandra Manning notification will always associate with the life. The reality, knowledge, science, health and wellness, faith, home entertainment, and also a lot more could be found in created e-books. Many writers supply their encounter, scientific research, research, as well as all points to share with you. Among them is via this What This Cruel War Was Over: Soldiers, Slavery, And The Civil War, By Chandra Manning This e-book What This Cruel War Was Over: Soldiers, Slavery, And The Civil War, By Chandra Manning will supply the required of notification and also statement of the life. Life will certainly be completed if you understand a lot more points through reading books.
From the explanation over, it is clear that you require to read this e-book What This Cruel War Was Over: Soldiers, Slavery, And The Civil War, By Chandra Manning We give the on the internet e-book qualified What This Cruel War Was Over: Soldiers, Slavery, And The Civil War, By Chandra Manning right here by clicking the web link download. From discussed publication by on the internet, you can offer much more benefits for several individuals. Besides, the viewers will be additionally quickly to obtain the preferred book What This Cruel War Was Over: Soldiers, Slavery, And The Civil War, By Chandra Manning to check out. Discover one of the most favourite and required book What This Cruel War Was Over: Soldiers, Slavery, And The Civil War, By Chandra Manning to review now as well as here.
In this unprecedented account, Chandra Manning uses letters, diaries, and regimental newspapers to take the reader inside the minds of Civil War soldiers-black and white, Northern and Southern-as they fought and marched across a divided country. With stunning poise and narrative verve, Manning explores how the Union and Confederate soldiers came to identify slavery as the central issue of the war and what that meant for a tumultuous nation. This is a brilliant and eye-opening debut and an invaluable addition to our understanding of the Civil War as it has never been rendered before.
- Sales Rank: #112897 in Books
- Published on: 2008-03-11
- Released on: 2008-03-11
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 7.98" h x .77" w x 5.19" l, .74 pounds
- Binding: Paperback
- 368 pages
From Publishers Weekly
Starred Review. For this impressively researched Civil War social history, Georgetown assistant history professor Manning visited more than two dozen states to comb though archives and libraries for primary source material, mostly diaries and letters of men who fought on both sides in the Civil War, along with more than 100 regimental newspapers. The result is an engagingly written, convincingly argued social history with a point—that those who did the fighting in the Union and Confederate armies "plainly identified slavery as the root of the Civil War." Manning backs up her contention with hundreds of first-person testimonies written at the time, rather than often-unreliable after-the-fact memoirs. While most Civil War narratives lean heavily on officers, Easterners and men who fought in Virginia, Manning casts a much broader net. She includes immigrants, African-Americans and western fighters, in order, she says, "to approximate cross sections of the actual Union and Confederate ranks." Based on the author's dissertation, the book is free of academese and appeals to a general audience, though Manning's harsh condemnation of white Southerners' feelings about slavery and her unstinting praise of Union soldiers' "commitment to emancipation" take a step beyond scholarly objectivity. Photos. (Apr.)
Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
From Booklist
Manning's subject--slavery as the prime cause of the Civil War--is hardly unusual, but what makes this study unique, provocative, and immensely valuable is her approach. She utilizes the letters, diaries, and regimental newspapers, all written during the war, to glean the attitudes, hopes, and even the fears of soldiers toward the institution of slavery and emancipation. Unlike many previous works on the subject, Manning ignores the writings of elites and emphasizes the opinions of common soldiers, North and South, white and black. Some of her conclusions are striking and likely to generate intense debate. Although acknowledging that many Union soldiers enlisted to preserve the Union rather than to fight slavery, she asserts that both slavery and emancipation were constant topics of discussion as early as 1861. She disputes that nonslaveholding Confederate soldiers (who were the overwhelming majority) fought primarily to defend hearth and home from Yankee invaders. Rather, she maintains that the defense of slavery was intimately tied to their sense of manhood, honor, and their place in the Southern social structures. A well-argued examination. Jay Freeman
Copyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved
Review
“An essential contribution to our understanding of slavery and the Civil War.” —The Philadelphia Inquirer
“A breathtakingly thorough examination of attitudes toward slavery of the rank-and-file troops, blue and gray, black and white.”
—The Baltimore Sun
“An engrossing study of Civil War soldiers . . . by breathing life into them, she breathes life into debates over why the war came and how it was waged.” —Chicago Tribune
“A splendid book that should be read carefully by all who have an interest in the Civil War.” —Civil War News
Most helpful customer reviews
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful.
Review of Kindle Edition: No hyperlinked endnotes.
By Bill
Review of the Kindle Edition. Note, this review is not a commentary on the argument of the book or on writing quality. It is a very important book, and has been a touchstone for debates among historians. I post it as a warning to those who are trying to decide on whether to buy the paper or ebook version. The endnotes in the ebook version are NOT hyper-linked, making it extremely difficult to quickly reference the very valuable notes as you read. There really is no excuse for a book this recent to not include hyper-linked notes, and shame on the publisher for not bothering to take the time to include this feature. For that reason, if you are a reader who needs to read endnotes, you may find it easier to access them in the paper version.
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful.
Review #19- Scott Johnston
By Scott Johnston
In Chandra Manning's work, What this Cruel War was Over, Manning utilizes a plethora of personal though of soldiers in the Civil War. This fresh perspective on the war gives new light to the most sought after topic in American history.
In this monograph one will not find an account of historical military, political or social events. However, this does provide what individual soldiers' feelings toward the lack of food and provisions in the Confederacy, or how they dealt with no shoes as the war went on, or even why they felt God was preventing their victory through their own indulgences.
Manning takes on a whole new level of individual social-history which is smartly written and quite through in its own respect. This is a great work to better understand public thought during the war rather than the political thought which ever other historian has already written on. I recommend this in compilation with any other political Civil War monograph to better understand the full picture of the war and era.
39 of 43 people found the following review helpful.
How she did her research and what she found
By greg taylor
It is my opinion that this book is the beginning of the end for the claim that the predominant cause of the Civil War wasn't slavery. Slavery was the primary single issue and it was the issue that energized most of the other issues that contributed to the war. Having stated that, I intend simply to summarize how she did her research and some of her conclusions.
Manning's book is the beginning of the end for other causal explanations because she relies on the testimonies that should bear the most weight, i.e., the wartime letters home of the men in blue and gray who fought at Gettysburg, Vicksburg, the Wilderness, Cold Harbor, Shiloh and all the other horrific battles of the war.
Her research is pretty amazing and should first be assessed by looking at her list of Primary Sources in the back of the book which is organized by state. She traveled to every state that was involved in the Civil War and roamed through 45 local libraries and historical societies. She went through larger collections like those of Military History Institute of the U.S. Army and the Library of Congress. She read published collections of Civil War letters and innumerable state documents relating to the War.
Her focus was on the enlisted man and on letters actually written during the war rather than memoirs that were written in the postwar years. She gathered biographical data of the various correspondents whose letters she collected and noted their place of origin, their occupation, educational attainments, etc. She then selected 477 Confederate soldiers and 657 Union soldiers to focus on because their collected backgrounds were representative of the armies as a whole.
She also uncovered some 100+ regimental papers (largely published by enlisted men) and used them as well. She then organized this body of material by date. Not surprisingly, she found that opinions shifted with the fortunes of the war.
Finally, for any one opinion to be considered dominant, it had to be expressed by at least a three to one ratio (p.11). By the way, all this is explained in the first twenty pages, so any reviewer who claims she used a different research strategy or that she can't back up any of her claims with "facts" hasn't read the book.
Her presentation of what she learned is very well written and easy to follow. She largely organized her presentation around the timeline of the war. She then covers what was being discussed in the letters of the Confederate Army and the Union Army both white and black.
I think she has three hermeneutics that she deploys on the material. First is the vast ornate interplay of slavery and racism within American culture at the time. Manning is very clear about the racist attitudes of many of the Union soldiers throughout the war and is clear about the way the black soldiers were mistreated, especially initially, by the higher command of that Army. But she believes that their letters show that during the course of the War, that enlisted white Union soldiers went through several shifts in their attitudes toward slavery and toward black Americans. Those shifts she sees as largely progressive and in advance of the chain of command and Northern public opinion as a whole. The War radicalized the soldiers. Most of them had never seen Southern slave society at work and they didn't much cotton to it. Their own racism took longer to be impacted. But for many Union soldiers, watching black Americans in battle was a revelation and a catalyst to personal change. There was backsliding during changes in the momentum of the War, there was frustration by the white soldiers at how much they were sacrificing and some of the soldiers left their service as racist as they entered it. But Manning is clear that there was a enormous change in the opinion of the white enlisted man as a whole and in the higher command. At the end of the war, the black Union soldier received equal pay and could become an officer. This was unthinkable four years earlier.
Manning's other two hermeneutics are more controversial and are probably the source of most of the resistance to her reading of the evidence. Manning feels that she can discern differences in the patriotism of the Confederate soldier and that of the Union soldier. It is her claim that the average Southerner regarded government as justifiable only to the extent it served his needs and that of his family. To the extent that that government began to impinge on his paternal control of his own life and his family was to the extent that the Southerner rejected government. By the way, she sees a related dynamic in the ways that the North and the South responded to the Second Great Awakening and its aftermath in antebellum America. That religious movement created organized reform movements in the North that focused on societal issues (among others, abolition). In the South, the emphasis was on the personal reform of the individual.
When the Southern states succeeded, they created a new national government to which the white Southern man had few if any attachments. As the War went on, the Confederate government had to behave in ways that didn't fit in with Southern ideas on government. To that extent, the Confederate soldier felt less loyalty to that government. The difference with the Northern white soldier should be clear. Billy Yank had a history with his government. He regarded that government as part of his larger society that provided services and to which he owed allegiance.
This difference cuts across her third hermeneutic which deals with the nature of Southern versus Northern manhood. Manning feels that for the enlisted white Confederate, slavery created a social structure which gave him the space to express that paternalistic manhood. His service on slave patrols, his ability to discipline slaves who were not respectful and other rights that the poor white non-slaveholding man had compared with a slave gave him a sense of equality with the upper Southern masters. Obviously, this is the most controversial portion of Manning's reading of the Southern men's letters but she uses it to explain a lot.
Another aspect of Manning's version of Southern manhood was rooted in fear and violence. The South had been traumatized by actual and possible slave rebellions. In some parts of the South, the slaves outnumbered the whites. Race war seemed a real possibility if the slaves were ever to be successfully armed and encouraged. The War and the Union Army did just that. The Southern soldier believed that he was fighting for the physical safety of his own family and for his own farm. Manning feels he fought to preserve the world he knew and wherein he had his place.
This reading is how Manning confronts one of the common arguments against slavery being the main cause of the war. The fact is that the vast majority of Southern white men did not own slaves. Why would all these men choose to fight and die over something they had no stake in? Manning's answer is that the Southern man fought for the world he knew and loved and wanted to leave to his children. The Confederate soldier knew that world was built on slave labor.
As I implied earlier, I found Manning's book to be utterly convincing. I would offer one more reason for reading her book. She uses an enormous amount of quotes. I detest the way the way we men talk about violence among ourselves- the fight stories, the "then I said" type stories that are told to maintain whatever it is they maintain. But I find the letters that are written home by American soldiers in war to be a unique and compelling literary genre. They are often poorly spelled and grammar is frequently taken to the woodshed but they are frequently funny and have a bedrock humanity which is enormously appealing. Reading some of Manning's quotes will make you wish you knew the men writing and could converse with them. Just another reason to read this very strong contribution to American history.
What This Cruel War Was Over: Soldiers, Slavery, and the Civil War, by Chandra Manning PDF
What This Cruel War Was Over: Soldiers, Slavery, and the Civil War, by Chandra Manning EPub
What This Cruel War Was Over: Soldiers, Slavery, and the Civil War, by Chandra Manning Doc
What This Cruel War Was Over: Soldiers, Slavery, and the Civil War, by Chandra Manning iBooks
What This Cruel War Was Over: Soldiers, Slavery, and the Civil War, by Chandra Manning rtf
What This Cruel War Was Over: Soldiers, Slavery, and the Civil War, by Chandra Manning Mobipocket
What This Cruel War Was Over: Soldiers, Slavery, and the Civil War, by Chandra Manning Kindle
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar